Heart Of Darkness Lord Of The Flies Comparison Essay

More coursework: 1 - A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I - J | K - L | M | N - O | P - S | T | U - Y

Compartive essay heart of darkness and lord of the flies

It can be said that a certain degree of darkness lies within every person, but this darkness will not surface unless given the correct environment. The darkness, however, can emerge and ultimately destroy the person if not checked by reason. If one's inner darkness does surface, the victim then is given the opportunity to reach a point in personal growth, and to gain a sense of self-knowledge from it. That is, when one's darkness appears, one must learn from this experience how he or she can prevent similar results from occurring in the future. It is ultimately through self-knowledge that we gain the power to defeat our inner darkness, and all of its elements. Just as everyone has the potential for evil within themselves, we too have the potential for true goodness. In many literary works the author attempts to exemplify the evil which lies within by showing many characters which have been, or are being overcome by their inner darkness. In the novel Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad we see how Marlow's journey into his ultimate evil, into his inner self, can be a positive experience. By contrasting Marlow with Kurtz, who represents the absolute evil, we can see the two products of an inner evil which has emerged. Marlow, who defeats his evil, and gains self-knowledge, and Kurtz, who is defeated by his darkness and falls prey to its wrath. In William Golding's Lord of the Flies the author points out how easily people can be over taken by the darkness, how the potential for good can be destroyed by the evil, but ideally how good will triumph. Through an examination of these two works we can see how the darkness within, given the correct environment will surface. The circumstances which eventually cause the appearance of the inner darkness in these two novels stems from the lack of civility, the true test, or journey which every life contains, and finally the product of evil which lies in all of us, either through acts of commission or omission.

When people lack the aspect of civility in their lives they too will lack the restraints and barriers it has on one's inner evil. Civility, in essence, provides the basic structure for good. Through laws, structure, and general order, goodness then, for the most part will be the end product. Therefore a lack of civility would result in a lack of order, morals, and laws, leaving chaos to over power. The desolate island in The Lord of the Flies represents a lack of civility. Without parents, law makers, and guardians the darkness which surfaces is inevitable. Piggy said in a feared state upon this realization: "This is an island? Well I think this is an island! That's a reef out in the sea. That means we are all alone! Perhaps there aren't any grownups anywhere" (Golding 4). It is clear that the civilization of the modern world is unavailable on the island. Although Ralph, who represented the aspect of order, attempts to reach a point of civility, unfortunately was unsuccessful. He said in his struggle: "We've got to have rules and obey them. After all we're not savages. We're English, and the English are the best at everything" (Golding 25). Ironically the very group he was talking to broke order and formed the savage group known as the 'hunters'. Similarly Piggy too represents civility. He incorporates the conch which to aids in the order of the island. He is very fearful of the lack of civility and scared by the hunters. He feels that civility and order, although the ideal route, was going to be crushed, and with it him: "We can't do this, the savages, they would crush us" (Golding 54). It is quite obvious how the potential evil in a group of young boys unavoidably arises due to the lack of restraint and order. When the darkness surfaces Jack and his group of hunters gain no self-knowledge, and therefore can not reprieve themselves nor the evil which takes over.

A strong parallel can be drawn between the island in Lord of the Flies and The Congo in The Heart of Darkness. The Congo in is similarly used to represent the absence of restraint and order. The effect which is used exemplifies a lack of civility, which in turn provides the opportunity for the emergence of darkness. At the beginning of the novel Marlow begins his descent into the Congo, which presents a dark image of death and suffering.

It was a thing which looked as dead as the carcass of some

strange animal. I came upon more pieces of decaying

machinery, and a stack of rusty rails. To the left a clump

of trees in a twisted shady spot, the ground shook (Conrad 52).

The capacity for evil in the jungle is endless. This is illustrated through the natives which who go mad and begin killing. Marlow struggles but by realizing his potential for good, manages to contain his evil. Unfortunately the result was not the same for many others: "I don't know how this would have struck the others but to me the evil was unspeakable, but not undefeatable" (Conrad 85). The Congo and the lack of restraints it represents causes one to lose common sense. Without common sense the mind is deteriorated. It is also left twisted and functionally useless in regards to civilized thought or action. The power of mind in most cases is no match for the lack of order and the lack of reason for most of the Congo's inhabitants. Kurtz fell victim to this and his mind became extremely deteriorated due to the lack of order. He eventually finds his inner darkness come forth and essentially control all his thoughts and actions.

By comparing the two novels it is clear how one's inner darkness will surface without the restraints of civilization. In the case of Jack and the hunters, the children are accustom to civility, laws, and order. The fact that parents and teachers were always placing unwanted rules on them, probably caused an initial enjoyment of the lack of civility so much that the growing savageness within grew blindly. The darkness was being to rise. This is shown through Jack, when asked about the war paint he was wearing replied: "For hunting! Like in the wars, you know, dazzle paint! We look more savage!"(Golding 71) This can be compared to the darkness which surfaced in Kurtz and the natives of the Congo, however their darkness was the result of greed rather than ignorance. Unlike Jack and the hunters, the greed for money and power by Kurtz allowed his darkness, which controlled him in the end, to surface. The on going evil growing in Kurtz was not only a result of the jungle, but it was shown through it as well. As he gained more darkness the jungle thickened and became increasingly dangerous: "...as we crept on closer towards Kurtz the snags were thickining and the water becoming treacherous..." (Conrad 82) If civilized limits are placed upon society as a whole, the majority of people have the opportunity to contain the darkness within. If and when it occasionally surfaces then the knowledge which is gained through a civilized lifestyle will contain, and defeat the individual's darkness.

It is true that every person must undergo the ultimate test at some point of his or hers life time. The test between good and evil. This test can be as simple as small, daily difficulties, or as large as the general principle in which one bases his or hers life upon. Although many people will fail the test which are given to them, it is better to attempt the test and fail, than it is never to have taken it at all. Ralph and Piggy, who as well as representing civility, now also represent the goodness, or the 'passers' of this test of life. Through the many altercations with the hunters, those who have failed the test, we can observe the darkness beginning to rise. The ultimate dark figure, Jack, who hasn't even attempted the test, that is to be satisfied with one's dark lifestyle, shows how the journey of life presents us with the tasks and trials which we are tested upon. Piggy perhaps was the character who was presented with the most tests. Many times he almost lost his sense and civility, but he always prevailed. Piggy at the verge of losing his sense murmured: "Nobody knows where we are! Perhaps they knew before but they don't know now 'cos we'll never get there!" (Golding 36) Not soon after, however, Piggy regained his sensible approach to the situation. It is impossible for one person to pass every test that life gives them, but the important thing is that you learn from every test, pass or fail, one must gain self-knowledge from each altercation.

When Marlow's time came to take his test, it was not necessarily that he passed it, but more importantly he gains the self-knowledge needed in order to defeat the darkness within him. By containing his darkness and preventing the release of his evil, he allows a certain degree of goodness to surface. The result of one's ability to contain his or her darkness does not always equal goodness, but instead it represents the awareness gained from each test. The natives show through their savagery and murderous ways that they have subsequently failed to gain the desired self-knowledge to maintain their goodness. Kurtz can be viewed as the character in the novel who doesn't attempt to take life's challenges and at length seals his dark fate. Marlow's first view of Kurtz shows how the goodness, and evil fail to co-exist together:

Seeing Kurtz for the first time, It was a distant glimpse:

the dugout, four paddling savages, and the lone white

man turning his back suddenly on the headquarters, on

relief, on thoughts of home--perhaps; setting his face

towards the depths of the wilderness, towards his

empty and desolate station (Conrad 75).

Had Kurtz even attempted the journey or test he was faced with perhaps he may have seen things in a different light. The natives on the other hand appear ignorant, but at the same time they appear content with their lifestyles.

The two novels can be compared in many ways according to the characters, and the tests they take along the journey of their lives. Piggy and Ralph can be compared to Marlow in the fact that they had either passed the test or clearly gained the self-knowledge to prevent the potential darkness within themselves from escaping. The two groups, the 'hunters' and the 'natives' can be similarly compared in terms regarding the characters who attempted to take the test but failed, an action which can, but not in these two cases, result in self-knowledge. Finally the two symbols of true darkness, Kurtz and Jack. The darkness within them surfaced due to that fact that not only did they fail to take the test of life, but they appeared to be content with the situation that this left them in.

The evil which lies within all of us has a third and final way of showing itself. This is exemplified through acts of commission, and through acts of omission. Edmund Burke was quoted as saying "Evil happens when good men do but nothing" (Encarta {Quotations}). The actions which one commits, or fails to commit, can act as a channel in which evil or darkness will begin show. The dark forces which lay in Jack and his group were confirmed by their final direct actions. The action which reiterated the darkness in Jack was the murder of Piggy. The murder was very brutal, and unnecessary: "The rock that had killed Piggy had bounded into the thicket and bounced there, landing in the middle for all to see" (Golding 230). Not only had they committed the murder but they indirectly reinforced their desire to deny civilization, as Piggy represented this. Earlier in the novel when Jack, and the hunters, directly disregarded civilization, they performed their first act of omission. This coupled with the savagery they possessed, showed a distinct lack of reason and reality, two of the key components to maintaining one's inner goodness. Finally the murder of Simon, who represented the Christ figure in the book, was the element which finalized Jack's descent into a irretrievable darkness.

Through the acts of commission and omission in Heart of Darkness, it is clear how the same actions, by separate people, can result in differing consequences. Marlow and Kurtz both live within the treacherous Congo, and are involved in the sales of ivory to gain power and wealth. The greed and stubbornness shown by the two men is very similar, but the result divers. Due to Kurtz's inner darkness which had risen, his downfall was evident. But through Marlow's ability to gain the self-knowledge required he was able to prevent his evil from emerging, which in turn would lead to his eventual demise. The natives on the other hand represent an indirect act of omission in which they were unable to obtain any knowledge. When the evil within them begins to surface they begin to break down mentally and physically. They become fierce, then eventually cataclysmic. They allow their true inner evil to take over, and they lose all capacity to gain any self-knowledge, which may have averted this catastrophe.

The characters in the novels again are comparative with respect to direct and indirect actions. Marlow and Ralph, through all the hardships and lack of civility, overcome the test of life, and finally prevent their own actions from surfacing their inner darkness. They are alike as they gain the essential knowledge to prevent this potential evil from taking its course. The natives and hunters find themselves in a situation in which, although they have committed few actions, have by-passed the opportunity to gain the smallest amount of knowledge, let alone the amount needed for to prevent future evil occurrences. Finally, Kurtz and Jack through their direct and deliberate actions place themselves in a position where it is obvious that self-knowledge and control is not what they desire, but instead the inner darkness which controls them to surface. When one is in the position of gaining self-knowledge, or materialistic amounts, we are faced with one of the greatest and most true tests of life, it is imperative that one takes the test, for you can not avoid the test by attempting to gain both.

Through examining the many different images which allow one's inner evil to surface, the lack of civility and restraints for good, the test which we must endure through life, and evil through commission and omission, it is evident how evil, if not checked by reality, reason, and imagination can surface in real life situations. Even in today's society with the amount of civility we posses, inner darkness may arise in many ways. This is predominate in direct actions, but appropriately too through those omission. With the potential for evil so great in today's materialistic, difficult society, we find ourselves with the difficult task of taking life's many journeys and tests. Not every journey will result in goodness, and the ones that do not are a learning experience in which must gain the self-knowledge to prevent our inner darkness from emerging. We must also be able to take the knowledge with us through every experience we encounter and incorporate it into our daily lives.


Not what you're looking for?

If this essay isn't quite what you're looking for, why not order your own custom Coursework essay, dissertation or piece of coursework that answers your exact question? There are UK writers just like me on hand, waiting to help you. Each of us is qualified to a high level in our area of expertise, and we can write you a fully researched, fully referenced complete original answer to your essay question. Just complete our simple order form and you could have your customised Coursework work in your email box, in as little as 3 hours.

Linda Senior Lecturer in Economics, Essay UK Researcher Team.

Lord of the Flies delves into the subject of ‘the darkness of man’s heart’. It explores the primitivism and savagery that comes with the human nature through the various characters and language choices. William Golding uses the concept of ‘fear of the unknown’ to show how it creates apprehension amongst the boys which leads to their chaotic behaviour. He explores the result of the absence of authority and order within a society. Golding also uses the boy’s conception of the ‘beastie’ as a symbol of the ‘beast’ within us.

The theme of ‘fear of the unknown’ runs throughout the book and is represented through the boys' fear of the beast and the island. Fear first starts to appear at nightfall, when the younger boys have appearances of monstrous creatures in their dreams. The boys start wondering if they were in fact not alone on the island and start doubting their safety. “Ralph’s right of course. There isn’t a snake-thing. But if there was a snake we’d hunt and kill it. We’re going to hunt pigs to get meat for everybody. And we’ll look for the snake too.” (p 48) In this quote, Jack’s repetition of the...

Join Now to View Premium Content

GradeSaver provides access to 901 study guide PDFs and quizzes, 7147 literature essays, 2000 sample college application essays, 296 lesson plans, and ad-free surfing in this premium content, “Members Only” section of the site! Membership includes a 10% discount on all editing orders.

Join Now

Already a member? Log in

0 Thoughts to “Heart Of Darkness Lord Of The Flies Comparison Essay

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *